Explanation of vote by First Deputy Permanent Representative Dmitry Polyanskiy before UNSC vote on a draft resolution on establishing a SC Commission to investigate into claims presented in the complaint lodged by the Russian Federation under Article 6 of the BTWC
Mr.President,
The vote that we are about to have will mark an important milestone for the Security Council. We will need to determine whether the Council reiterates its readiness to act in accordance with international law, in this particular case – the Convention on Biological and Toxin Weapons (BTWC).
We provided a detailed elaboration of our position at the meeting on 27 October, so I will not repeat it now. Then we hosted two rounds of expert consultations on the draft resolution. However all we heard were the dated points of our former Western partners regarding the “Russian propaganda” and claims that our evidence was allegedly little convincing and not worth further consideration. They articulated those findings unilaterally and preempted any conclusions of the Council. Basically, they substituted the decisions of the key UN body, which is responsible for maintaining the international peace and security, with their biased assessments made in national capacity.
We regret that our Western colleagues in fact sabotaged the negotiations process on the draft resolution. It is now obvious that Western states are simply afraid that a Commission may be created to look into the materials submitted by the Russian Federation and conduct a relevant investigation as envisaged by the BTWC. What they are particularly unhappy about is that the Commission would include all members of the Security Council, which would not let the Western countries try and make decisions unilaterally on behalf of the entire international community. As for other forms of international cooperation, they dismiss them as something incompatible with the “rules-based order” concept that they are promoting ardently, and that should let them set all the rules by themselves. The accusations of Western countries or Ukraine against us without providing any evidence are immediately presented as the ultimate truth. But as soon as we raise our concerns having backed them with concrete evidence, we become blamed for spreading propaganda. As for the UN Charter and international law in general, Western countries only remember about those when they need to. Thereby they strongly reject the idea that these norms can and should be applied to the West as well. The engagement on our draft resolution vividly confirms this.
We hope that respect for the norms of international law, including the BTWC, will prevail in the Council today, and that those delegations who are committed to international law and do not fear pursuing an independent policy that may anger Washington, will support our draft resolution.
Thank you.
Explanation of vote by First Deputy Permanent Representative Dmitry Polyanskiy after UNSC vote on a draft resolution on establishing a SC Commission to investigate into claims presented in the complaint lodged by the Russian Federation under Article 6 of the BTWC
Mr.President,
We regret that the Council failed to invoke the mechanism provided for in Article 6 of the Biological and Toxin Weapons Convention (BTWC). I remind that according to the BTWC, “each state party to the Convention undertakes to co-operate in carrying out any investigation which the Security Council may initiate, in accordance with the provisions of the Charter of the United Nations, on the basis of the complaint received by the Council.”
During the elaboration process of this draft resolution, Western states demonstrated in every possible way that they placed themselves above the law and were not going to implement this provision. They proved ready to trample on every norms and infringe on every rule – in line with the colonial thinking that they are accustomed to. We have long ceased to be surprised by that.
Regardless of the results of today’s vote, we retain our questions to the United States and Ukraine. The materials that were attached to our complaint still require clarification.
We will continue to act within the BTWC framework and make the necessary efforts to establish all the facts related to the violation by the United States and Ukraine of obligations under the BTWC in the context of the activities of biological laboratories on Ukrainian territory. Sooner or later, all perpetrators will have to be accountable for such illegal activities in front of the global community anyway. We will continue taking efforts to strengthen the BTWC regime in the interests of ensuring our national, as well as regional and global security. In particular, we will take such efforts during the Ninth Review Conference of the Convention that is scheduled to take place in Geneva on November 28 – December 16, 2022.
Thank you.
PERMANENT MISSION
OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION TO THE UNITED NATIONS
INTERNATIONALIST 360° 