Nicaragua, the Country that Didn’t Swallow the Covid Blue Pill

Jorge Capelán

Children of a barrio in Managua celebrating the anniversary of the excecution of dictator Anastasio Somoza García in 1956. (Photo: Jorge Capelán)

No curfews, no lockdowns, no “stay at home”, no psychosis, no covid-calamities. There has been much talk about the Swedish corona strategy but the strategy of Nicaragua has been by far more successful, with many fewer deaths, no “economic rescue” for big banks and only limited damage to small and medium sized businesses.

In the midst of the worldwide economic debacle caused by covid hysteria, food self-sufficient, small business based, impoverished Nicaragua, has seen its exports grow over 10% the past 8 months because it did not shut down its economy. Precisely because it sustained its economy, it has not had to take on huge loans in order to face the emergency. Thus, its foreign debt levels remain within a readily manageable range, below 50% of GDP. (On the other hand, the economies of neighboring countries such as Costa Rica, El Salvador, Honduras and Guatemala, are hurting badly with debt levels soaring).

Image: ourworldindata.org

I went out on Sunday afternoon in the barrio where I live in Managua. Bars full of people, even small family-run restaurants full of guests. No masks. The local convenience store which still has the “only-masked-customers-allowed” sign hanging from the door no longer refuses to let maskless people in.

There is no mask-wearing official policy in Nicaragua except for a recomendation that only patients with respiratory conditions or personnel taking care of them should wear masks. The wearing of surgical gloves by patients, on the other hand, is strongly discouraged as it poses a serious risk of contagion both of coronavirus and other respiratory deseases. In hospitals and health care units most people wear masks, be it out of precaution or out of plain courtesy. Otherwise, in offices and shops handwashing and alcohol hand sanitizers are readily available practically everywhere.

No restrictions have been put in place for public meetings and sports championships such as the popular local baseball league have taken place without problems, as well as scores of local fairs and other traditional activities that take place weekly.

Few massive activities have been cancelled due to covid, especially Catholic Church processions, most notably the traditional 10-day-long celebrations of Saint Dominic in Managua, for which thousands of people gather every year. For the most part, people have moved around, going out or heading to the beach as normal. Over the last 3 weeks, an all-time record number of over 83 thousand people visited the Salvador Allende Port and its lakeside promenade – a big and popular public leisure complex in Managua–, according to the authorities.

Schools haven’t closed down, which is very good for the country’s school children, since they provide a nutritious meal a day to 1.2 million children, a food security measure contributing greatly to improved public health for families across Nicaragua.

Yet, with just 2-3 covid-19 deaths per week the last couple of weeks (147 in total as of September 22nd), Nicaragua is by far the least affected country in Central America. Belice has only 19 deaths so far, but on the other hand, its population is a fraction of Nicaragua’s.

As in Germany and other countries, Nicaragua’s Health Ministery does differentiate between deaths of patients “with covid” and “from covid”. That is, a person can be with covid-19 but in the last instance die from an acute heart attack, while someone else who also has covid-19 can die “from covid-19” because of an upper lung condition typical of viruses that cause Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS), such as SARS-CoV-2. That is the official explanation given by the authorities in a white paper on Nicaragua’s public health response to the pandemic issued last May.

Athough increased mortality due to pneumonia has been noticed (last week, 26% fewer pneumonia cases were reported, but with an increase of 8% in deaths – related but not directly caused by covid), the situation in the hospitals, health care centers, funeral parlours and graveyards is totally normal. No collapse anywhere.

By the end of April and the beginning of May, when the majority of covid deaths were reported, many people lost acquaintances, relatives or friends with comorbidities, but not even back then did the situation reach the kinds of scenes taking place in other countries. The health system never came even close to saturation point at any time.

In the Western press Nicaragua has been portrayed as a country that “did nothing” to divert the pandemic, which is totally false. Very early on, on January 21st, while the wealthy countries of North America and Europe dallied, Nicaragua declared a national epidemiological alert. That was the day after the Chinese authorities reported that country’s third death from covid-19. Some weeks later, Nicaragua’s national covid response committee elaborated a detailed protocol based on strenghtening the public health system and informing the population on a mass scale.

The strategy followed by the Nicaraguan Government was based on informing the population, taking care of the elderly and frail and strengthening the public health system, specially via enhanced control of the many diseases already threatening the population such as zika, dengue, malaria and chikungunya. The ordinary public health campaigns never stopped, with fumigation of areas with high prevalence of mosquitoes as well as routine annual vaccination programmes for children and the elderly.

The population was recommended to intensify hygiene routines and those in the high-risk groups were recommended to avoid crowds. Every institution devised plans and protocols to meet the covid emergency and in industrial complexes such as the free trade zones plans were agreed between employers and the workers’ unions in order to ensure that any eventual interruptions to production would not leave working families without an income (luckily, as it turned out, for the most part production was not very seriously affected by the pandemic).

The Ministry of Health from the very beginning has provided epidemiological surveillance for people affected by epidemic diseases typical for the time of year: dengue, malaria (both vivax and falciparum), chikungunya, zika, pneumonia, tuberculosis, H1-N1, leptospirosis, chagas disease, as well ensuring care for chronic diseases, for example cancer treatment, renal dialysis or cardiology conditions.

People with respiratory problems, cough and flu, are being given special attention and follow-up, to determine if they need further monitoring depending on their corresponding chronic condition: diabetes mellitus, chronic kidney disease, stroke, hypertensive disease, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, pneumonia, among others.

A very successful initiative now being implemented is the program “My Hospital My Community” by which all public hospitals mobilize their specialized health care units out into their respective communities in order to actively reach out to people with various chronic conditions who for various reasons may have difficulties going to their local hospital –among them persons who are afraid of getting covid-19 if they go to a hospital.

As mentioned earlier, schools and universities have remained open because on-line distance learning is not an option for people on low incomes. However, because some parents were reluctant to send their children to school a specially designed series of television classes on all subjects have been produced and broadcast both on public television channels and on radio so that children could make good any classes they may have missed.

Facing the recurring risk of volcano eruptions, earthquakes, hurricanes as well as all the various kinds of tropical diseases, countries such as Nicaragua very much need to develop a routine system for early warning and management of emergencies, simply because those events are part of our everyday reality.

Nicaragua is among the countries most threatened by global warming and has been able to deal simply and readily with covid because since 2007 it has developed an integral civil defence and public health philosophy based on broad popular participation, a highly operational public sector and a system trained and ready to articulate cohesively all the available resources.

Whether addressing natural disasters or national public health challenges, Nicaragua over the years has built up an unrivalled organizational infrastructure that quickly mobilizes thousands of volunteer activists and public sector employees. So covid didn’t take the country unawares.

During the past 13 years Nicaragua has experienced dramatic advances. Back in 2006, before the Sandinistas returned to power, overall poverty was 48%. Today it is 24.6%. 54% of people had no electricity. Today, 98.5% have it. 70% didn’t have running water. Today 93% have it. Infant mortality was 29 per 1000 infants born. Today it is down to 12 per 1000 – a reduction of over 60%. Almost 9 out of 10 births now take place in health centers while before most children were delivered at home. In 2006 the country had 2044km of roads (only 30% in good condition). In 2019 the paved road network was 4590km (all in good repair). The economy grew from USD 6.7bn to 12.5bn in this period.

Amidst this development in a region cursed by neoliberalism, public health has played a central role in Sandinista policies. From the outset, privatization of health care was stopped and rolled back. A new, community and family-based preventive health model was developed using sector based territorial health areas grouping together communities of between 600 to 1,000 families, equivalent to 3,000 to 5,000 inhabitants, depending on whether the sector is rural or urban.

In each of these territories, so-called “cabinets for the family, community and life” have been organized incorporating socially-engaged members of society who effectively monitor the local health situation and are able to address not only sanitary and medical issues, but also the social aspects of public health, of particular importance.

For example, the program “Todos con Voz” (“Everyone with a Voice”) assesses the overall situation of each person with disability in a household and assists, not only with wheelchairs or therapies, but also with economic support and training in order to improve the economic activity available to the whole household. The program “Amor para los más chiquitos” (“Love for the littlest ones”) promotes better care in the family for very young children. Other programs are aimed at helping poor families with children in school age so that they don’t have to send their children to work and so on.

Public health investment has also seen a dramatic increase from USD 32 to USD 70 per capita (2018). Total health care expenditure went from USD 111.9 million to USD468.6 million in 2020. In 2006 there were 22,083 health workers; in 2020, there are 36,649, including doctors, nurses and technicians, many of them educated in Cuba and other countries.

The Sandinista government has built 18 new hospitals and there are plans to build 15 more, 6 of which are already under construction. The total health infrastructure of the country comprises 143 health centers; 1,333 medical posts; 178 maternity homes and 66 mobile clinics – way ahead per population of its Central American neighbors.

Nicaraguan authorities receive a Japan-funded linear accelerator to treat cancer patients. (Photo: Jefrey Poveda)

All this investment has a strong technological component as it shortens hospitalization periods, in many cases is much safer and makes more rational use of available health personnel. Among recent hi-tech investments are two linear accelerators to treat cancer (one of them has already been set in place, one is about to be installed) and the widespread use of laparoscopic surgeries and other modern techniques.

Recently, a molecular biology lab was inaugurated capable of analyzing evidence of several diseases, including COVID-19. This lab is the second most advanced in the region and has been recognized by the WHO as having Level 3 Biosafety.

Also, the Russian Mechnikov medicine factory was inaugurated, which can produce 12 million influenza vaccines per year. The Cuban drug Interferon Alpha-2B (successfully used to treat patients with COVID-19) is expected to be produced in this lab as well as the Russian Covid vaccine.

Hospitals, new and in progress
(Photo: El 19 Digital)

All this high-tech investment does not exclude the widespread use of traditional or natural medicine. A public health sector “Pain clinic” has been built to give treatment in acupuncture and many other traditional therapies, and specialists in those treatments are available in many health care facilities all over the country.

Nicaragua is a country where 80% of farmland holdings are under 875 acres, worked by small and medium sized producers. It is a country where small-scale family businesses drive the economy, controlling over 60% of disposable income, providing around 80% of the country’s employment and producing 90% of all the food it consumes. So while it simply cannot afford to “lock down” or “stay home”, conversely it didn’t need to take “extraordinary measures” to face the covid emergency because it already had an immensely resilient system designed and in permanent readiness to face any and every kind of emergency.

For Nicaragua, the “blue pill” of lockdown or “stay at home” would have been pure cyanide, and since its leadership long ago took the red pill, it was able to discern the true interests behind the phony rich-country pandemic discourse and its hidden “great re-set” agenda.

4 Comments

  1. Reader Comment (received through our contact form):

    I’m inspired by Nicaragua, but the pandemic polarised and provoked people to violent confrontations, debunking and smear campaigns. Did Cuba and Venezuela take the ‘covid blue pill’ because they implemented quarantines and masks? Is there another way to praise Nicaragua’s response without disregarding the good work of other countries? The truth is somewhere between the ‘covidians’ and ‘covidiots’, but definitely not to be found in either camp. It seems a great opportunity to bridge this gap was lost here.

    1. Reply from the Author:

      Hi, thank you for your questions/comments.

      Actually, the internal situation in Nicaragua today is not one of polarization – at all. What happened 2 years ago was just a failed coup. Although the putschists managed to sow confusion for a couple of weeks their agenda became very apparent very soon as they used their blockades to commit all sorts of crimes and abuses against ordinary citizens. It was a huge political harakiri for the right: Their old, already discredited cadres became even more discredited, and the new generation of cadres specially trained and coached by the US Embassy during the past decade just to participate in the failed coup have already been burned out.

      The right attempted to use de covid emergency in order to stir up anti-government sentiments, but they failed miserably. The proof of that is that people have gone out and carried out with their businesses always taking the protective measures recommended by the authorities. Western media convey a totally false picture of the pandemic in Nicaragua.

      About the political situation, one can say that about 35-40% of the people belong ideologically to the right and it will take generations to change an ideology people have been socialized into from very early age, but most of them know that the putschist way is a failed way. Only 10% (or even less) of the public opinion favors violence. On the other hand, about 90% or more of the people think that Nicaraguans must solve their own conflicts through democratic means and condemn foreign intervention. Besides, a very solid majority recognizes the basic legitimacy of the country’s institutions, including the sanitary authorities. One can say that those who oppose the Sandinista government in Nicaragua are in a profound state of lack of leadership, the right here is going through a serious existential crisis.

      About Nicaragua’s way of handling the covid emergency compared to Cuba and Venezuela, I would stress that – contrary to what is the norm in today’s world – all three countries have very strong public health systems. Also, it has to be stressed that both Cuba and Venezuela are being economically blocked in a way Nicaragua isn’t although Nicaragua is being subject to inhumane sanctions by the US. It is very difficult for the US today to block Nicaragua as Ronald Reagan did back in the 1980’s – it would seriously affect the whole region. Furthermore, both Venezuela and Cuba have tried to avoid hurting production as much as possible with their lock-down policies. However, personally I think that both Cuba and Venezuela will have to pay a much higher economic price than Nicaragua for having implemented the lock-down strategy. In Nicaragua it would have been suicidal. Besides, both Venezuela and Cuba will face serious challenges when they try to open up their economies again because of weakened overall immunity.

      One similarity between Nicaragua’s, Cuba’s and Venezuela’s covid strategies was popular participation. However, the point is that in spite of their differences, our strategies have more things in common than what many people believe.

    2. It is not clear if the original comment from a reader (from the USA) referred to polarization inside Nicaragua or general polarization as seen on social media and in most Western countries. The author’s remarks are relevant either way. Cuba, Venezuela and Nicaragua all had popular participation. In most other countries, restrictions were imposed in a climate of fear, with very little consistent, factual information and no services to support people impacted by the extreme measures…which naturally led to panic. Also, Nicaragua (as well as Venezuela and Cuba) took the threat seriously and began taking proactive measures immediately, while other countries did nothing for several months.

      Regarding polarization, is that not the modus operandi of empire? Rather than dispute the false binary generated by the “covidian or covidiot” factions, it is far more fruitful to focus on what this pandemic has revealed about empire. Capitalism, imperialism, war, oppression, destruction, are very real. But the alternatives to barbarism are also a reality we can choose. What needs to be dismantled so that all of humanity and our ecosystem can live free of oppression and exploitation? How do we dismantle it? What system can replace it? How do we need to change, both privately and collectively so we are up to the task?

      1. Internationalist 360° says:

        Reply from the Original Commenter received via the web contact form on October 1, 2020:

        Thanks to the author for his reply and to Internationalist 360 for publishing the comments.

        Let me briefly clarify. I support the Nicaraguan government and commend their efforts to contain the pandemic. But their success didn’t stem from denying the reality of SARS-CoV-2/COVID-19 but from recognition of its deadly potential. If you insist that the virus and the threat it poses are somehow fantastical, you diminish the FSLN’s accomplishments. They were effective in containing it because they took the right steps and we need to reproduce and advance it.

        It is a disservice to countries like Cuba and Venezuela working to combat the pandemic to suggest it isn’t a threat. This completely negates their narratives and plays into the hands of empire. No revolutionary movement anywhere in the world has denied the threat of the pandemic. The blue pill analogy implies idiocy and it’s frankly insulting.

        Internationalist 360 said,

        “Regarding polarization, is that not the modus operandi of empire? Rather than dispute the false binary generated by the “covidian or covidiot” factions, it is far more fruitful to focus on what this pandemic has revealed about empire.

        I agree and am wary of talking points advanced by the global fascist right, especially when the Left is struggling to survive the right-wing offensive. To be clear, I’m not implying the author is from that camp, but denying the threat posed by SARS-CoV-2/COVID-19 is a standard fascist tactic. Aligning with all progressive governments and social movements against fascism and empire is of paramount importance, not disputing the reality of the pandemic. The real left have always known fascism’s goal is total hegemony. If we’re drawn into false arguments we have no power to resist and that’s the pit empire’s dug for us. I don’t intend to fall into it.
        https://img-s-msn-com.akamaized.net/tenant/amp/entityid/BB16WLIx.img?h=0&w=720&m=6&q=60&u=t&o=f&l=f

        B.J. Newton Jr.

Comments are closed.